Traditional marketing is dead

Register or Login to like
Sky with clouds and grass

Flickr user: theaucitron (CC BY-SA 2.0)

The power of partners is incalculable. Again and again, open source communities prove that to all of us at Red Hat. The more smart people you assemble as you undertake an important endeavor, the more effective, flexible, and innovative the solutions you'll discover.

And yet that's not how the marketing business has traditionally worked.

Recently I've noticed a few writers and marketing industry pundits proclaiming the death of "agencies of record"—those gigantic, one-stop-shops capable of exclusively handling clients' every need (think Mad Men). Today, marketing organizations are turning to more diverse, expert sets of boutique firms to help them with their marketing challenges.

Just like most other industries, marketing agencies are experiencing fundamental disruptions to their business models. However, there's disagreement about what these current trends signal for the future of long-term retainers and agencies of record. Writing in Advertising Age, for example, Michael Farmer called the death of the agency of record "unfortunate" and wrote that "the intellectual and economic idea behind the concept is terrible," something that "will accelerate the decline of agency abilities." Yet at The Drum, John Reid insists otherwise, commenting that "these trends aren't Madison Avenue's death knell," but instead "something incredibly valuable: an opportunity to do better."

I land on the side of "opportunity." I believe the "agency of record" has lost both its appeal and the power to deliver the best marketing today. Its death is not at all disastrous for us as marketers. It really is an opportunity: an opportunity to release ourselves from an obsolete and cumbersome system, to work with more effective and diverse partners, and to embrace something much more nimble, powerful, and innovative.

Something community-powered.

Saying goodbye to the agency of record

Make no mistake: Dealing with the changing nature of agency/client relationships does require work. As a marketing leader, you now need an innovative approach to coordinating, working with, and learning from the diverse groups of marketing partners that you can enlist to help you achieve your goals. Quite frankly, this means treating these agencies like a community: bringing them along with you on your journey, rather than asking them to deliver project work.

Let me back up a minute.

My many years in marketing have taught me the power of this community-powered approach. I last employed an agency of record, Leo Burnett, more than a decade ago—and I don't have fond memories of the experience. At the time, I was working at Delta Air Lines, and I remember great ideas getting buried in the agency's hierarchies and agency leaders talking to our CEO like they were in charge of our marketing strategy. When something went wrong, my marketers were quick to blame the agency. Something about the relationship felt wrong. But what was I to do differently?

I walked away from that agency.

Instead, I hired smaller agencies proficient in more focused and specific areas of expertise. Actually, I shifted away from the agency "request for proposals" process entirely and instead hired firms to execute small projects and prove their value. I took charge of who was doing what. I coordinated all the contributions. I crafted strict rules and guidelines. I outlined the swim lanes clearly. I made sure we were on budget. Sometimes, I even asked two agencies to deliver the same project to get a better answer.

But I hadn't yet made the turn to a community-powered approach.

It takes an ecosystem

It wasn't until I found myself at Red Hat, where community is the heart and soul of our approach to everything we do that the light bulb came on. I wondered: What if we unite these agencies with a common purpose, share the necessary Red Hat context (rather than specific rules) so they can act autonomously, build solid relationships of trust and respect, ask them to work alongside one another, and inspire them to be a part of our journey? Wouldn't we have a higher likelihood of getting their best work?

The answer? A resounding yes.

At Red Hat, we now engage our community of external marketing agencies the same way we treat our broader open source communities: as an ecosystem of innovators whose power to produce results far outstrips anything we could do on our own. That means completely changing our approach to working with these agencies—so we can maximize the power of partners that's so integral to our success.

And in my next article, I'll explain exactly how we do it.

User profile image.
Chief Marketing Officer at Ellucian

3 Comments

Jackie, you said "Quite frankly, this means treating these agencies like a community: bringing them along with you on your journey, rather than asking them to deliver project work."

I believe that the transition you describe -- the death of traditional (obsolete) marketing -- also requires internal changes at Red Hat. The corporate marketer role now becomes more of a marketing practitioner (performing the essential work) and less of a program manager role (outsourcing the work to agencies and/or contractors).

In the same way that Red Hat software developers are active "contributors" to open source communities, the digital marketers of today must also *practice* their profession -- research markets, conceive strategy and create meaningful and substantive narrative that engages and inspires customers and other stakeholders in the Red Hat ecosystem.

Would you consider this progressive view of 21st Century market development?

My point: at the recognized market leaders in the technology space, the focal point is not the agencies, it's developing the internal talent (employees) to become meaningful and substantive influencers of sentiment towards the brand. When you embrace this reality, then you can truly evolve. You totally let go of the past. Live in the present. Create the compelling content.

David,

Thanks for reading and commenting. I agree with you that the role of any marketer today is not just as a manager of activities (or agencies) but to also be ingrained in their practice and "doers" themselves. Especially since the marketing world is changing so rapidly. My goal wasn't to suggest that we only rely on external agencies; that's far from the truth. I’m a believer in a healthy mix of internal and external creation—to help scale and to bring in fresh perspectives and expertise.

I’m extremely proud of the work our in-house marketing team does. It is actually more than any marketing organization I’ve been a part of. Two recent examples: 1) Open Source Stories: https://www.redhat.com/en/open-source-stories; 2) our creative team's blog, Red Hat Open Studio: http://openstudio.redhat.com/. You can expect us to share even more work like this.

My goal with this post was to discuss the way in which marketing teams engage with their agencies—as partners, a rich eco-system, and communities—rather than as vendors.

In reply to by David H. Deans

Thank you, Jackie, for your thoughtful response to my perspective, and related question. We're all being challenged to seek out the most effective ways to stay current in the field of marketing. Therefore, perhaps in a follow-on editorial, you might consider explaining how you're responding to the ongoing demand for marketing employee digital skills training and mentoring. That would likely be very insightful to your readers.

In reply to by Jackie Yeaney

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International License.